Book chapter

Looking for the islands of equality in a sea of inequality. Why did some societies in pre-industrial Europe have relatively low levels of wealth inequality?

Bas Van Bavel
Utrecht University, Netherlands - ORCID: 0000-0001-8686-0279


ABOUT THIS CHAPTER

This paper scrutinizes the insights won by recent studies in wealth inequality in pre-industrial Europe. It focuses on the regions and periods where levels of inequality were relatively low, trying to arrive at an inventory of causes of these exceptions. It discusses catastrophic events, colonization and revolution as possible causes, but argues that these only occasionally had a leveling effect, depending on the social and institutional context in which they occurred. Most clearly wealth accumulation was restricted, even by maximums on ownership, where associative organizations held a solid position, and market and state played lesser roles as coordination systems.
Read more

Keywords: Economic inequality, economic history, European economic history, pre-industrial age

Formats

PDF

Pages: 431-456

Published by: Firenze University Press

Publication year: 2020

DOI: 10.36253/978-88-5518-053-5.27

Download PDF

© 2020 Author(s)
Content licence CC BY 4.0
Metadata licence CC0 1.0

XML

Publication year: 2020

DOI: 10.36253/978-88-5518-053-5.27

Download XML

© 2020 Author(s)
Content licence CC BY 4.0
Metadata licence CC0 1.0

References

  1. Anon, 1993. The making of a bourgeois state: war, politics and finance during the Dutch revolt. Choice Reviews Online, 30(11), pp.30–6331–30–6331 10.5860/choice.30-6331
  2. Acemoglu D. and Robinson J.A. (2002), The political economy of the Kuznets curve, «Review of Development Economics», 6, 2: 183-203.
  3. Acemoglu D. and Robinson J.A. (2012), Why Nations Fail. The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty, New York.
  4. Alfani G. (2013), Calamities and the Economy in Renaissance Italy. The Grand Tour of the Horsemen of the Apocalypse, New York.
  5. Alfani G. and Ammannati F. (2017), Long-term trends in economic inequality. The case of the Florentine state, «Economic History Review», 70, 4: 1072-1102.
  6. Alfani G. and Di Tullio M. (2019), The Lion’s Share: Inequality and the rise of the fiscal state in preindustrial Europe, Cambridge.
  7. Alfani G. and Ryckbosch W. (2016), Growing apart in early modern Europe? A comparison of inequality trends in Italy and the Low Countries, 1500–1800, «Explorations in Economic History», 62: 143-153.
  8. Alfani G., Gierok V. and Schaff F. (forthcoming), Economic inequality in preindustrial Germany: a long-run view (fourteenth to nineteenth centuries).
  9. Allemeyer M.L. (2007), Fewersnoth und Flammenschwert. Stadtbrände in der Frühen Neuzeit, Göttingen.
  10. Ammannati F. (2015), La Peste Nera e la distribuzione della proprietà nella Lucchesia del tardo Medioevo, «Popolazione e Storia», 2: 21-45.
  11. Aylmer G.E. (1975), The Levellers in the English Revolution, Ithaca.
  12. Blockmans W. (1989), Voracious states and obstructing cities: An aspect of state formation in preindustrial Europe, «Theory and Society», 18, 5: 733-755.
  13. Borgerhoff Mulder M. et al. (2009), Intergenerational wealth transmission and the dynamics of inequality in small-scale societies, «Science» 326, 5953: 682-688.
  14. Brenner R. (1995), The agrarian roots of European capitalism, in Aston T.H. and Philpin C.H.E. (eds.), The Brenner Debate. Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe, Cambridge: 213-327.
  15. Caferro W.P. (2008), Warfare and economy in Renaissance Italy, 1350-1450, «The Journal of Interdisciplinary History», 39: 167-210.
  16. Cooper J.P. (1976), Patterns of inheritance and settlement by great landowners from the fifteenth to the eighteenth centuries, in Goody J., Thirsk J. and Thompson E.P. (eds.), Family and inheritance: rural society in western Europe, 1200-1800, Cambridge: 192-327.
  17. Curtis D. (2016), Did the Commons Make Medieval and Early Modern Rural Societies More Equitable? A Survey of Evidence from across Western Europe, 1300–1800, «Journal of Agrarian Change» 16, 4: 646-664.
  18. Curtis D.R. (2012), Florence and its hinterlands in the late Middle Ages. Contrasting fortunes in the Tuscan countryside, 1300-1500, «Journal of Medieval History», 38, 4: 472-499.
  19. Curtis D.R. (2016), Danger and displacement in the Dollard. The 1509 flooding of the Dollard Sea (Groningen) and its impact on long-term inequality in the distribution of property, «Environment and History», 22, 1: 103-135.
  20. De Keyzer M. (2014), The Common Denominator. The Survival of the Commons in the Late Medieval Campine Area, University of Antwerp, Antwerp.
  21. de Moor T. (2008), The silent revolution: A new perspective on the emergence of commons, guilds, and other forms of corporate collective action in western Europe, «International Review of Social History», 53, 16: 179-212.
  22. Di Tullio M. (2018), Cooperating in time of crisis. War, commons, and inequality in Renaissance Lombardy, «Economic History Review», 71, 1: 82-105.
  23. Fochesato M. and Bowles S. (2015), Nordic exceptionalism? Social democratic egalitarianism in world-historic perspective, «Journal of Public Economics», 127: 30-44.
  24. Fourie J. (2012), An inquiry into the nature, causes and distribution of wealth in the Cape Colony, 1652-1795, Utrecht.
  25. Fritschy W., ‘t Hart M. C. and Horlings E. (2012), Long-term trends in the fiscal history of the Netherlands, 1515-1913, in Yun-Casalilla B. and O’Brien P.K. (eds.), The Rise of Fiscal States. A Global History 1500-1914, Cambridge.
  26. Genicot L. (1943), L’économie rurale namuroise au bas moyen âge, Louvain.
  27. Grapperhaus F.H.M. (1982), Alva en de tiende penning, Zutphen.
  28. Henderikx P.A. (1989), Die Mittelalterliche Kultivierung der Moore im Rhein-Maas Delta (10-13 Jahrhundert), in Siedlungsforschung. Archäologie-Geschichte-Geographie 7, Bonn.
  29. Jacquart J. (1975), La crise rurale en Ile-de-France (1550-1670), Paris.
  30. Jakubowski-Tiesen M. (1992), Sturmflut 1717. Die Bewältigung einer Naturkatastrophe in der Frühen Neuzeit, Munich.
  31. Klassen P.J. (1964), The Economics of Anabaptism. 1525-1560, London.
  32. Knottnerus O. (2004), Yeomen and farmers in the Wadden Sea coastal marshes, in Hoppenbrouwers P. and van Bavel B.J.P. (eds.), Landholding and Land Transfer in the North Sea Area (Late Middle Ages - 19th Century), CORN Publications 5, Turnhout: 149-186.
  33. Korzeniewicz R.P. and Moran T.P. (2005), Theorizing the relationship between inequality and economic growth, «Theory and Society», 34, 3: 277-316.
  34. Kowaleski M. (2015), Peasants and the sea in Medieval England, in Kowaleski M., Langdon J. and Schofield P.R. (eds.), Peasants and Lords in the Medieval English Economy, Turnhout: 363-369.
  35. Kulikoff A. (1992), The Agrarian Origins of American Capitalism, Charlottesville.
  36. Kuznets S. (1955), Economic growth and income inequality, «The American Economic Review», 45, 1: 1-28.
  37. Lachmann R. et al. (2000), Capitalists in Spite of Themselves. Elite Conflict and Economic Transitions in Early Modern Europe, Oxford.
  38. Mate M. (1992), The economic and social roots of medieval popular rebellion. Sussex in 1450‐1451, «The Economic History Review», 45, 4.
  39. Milanovic B. (2016), Global inequality: A new approach for the Age of Globalization, Cambridge-London.
  40. Milanovic B. (2018), Towards an explanation of inequality in premodern societies. The role of colonies, urbanization, and high population density, «Economic History Review», 71, 4: 1029-1047.
  41. Moorman van Kappen O. (1973), Met open buydel ende in baren gelde. Enkele beschouwingen over het oud-vaderlandse familienaastingsrecht, Deventer.
  42. Neveux H. (1980), Vie et déclin d’une structure économique, Paris-La Haye.
  43. Nicolini E. and Ramos Palencia F. (2016), Comparing income and wealth inequality in pre-industrial economies. Lessons from eighteenth century Spain, Working Paper in History and Economics Institutions, Universidad Pablo de Olavide de Sevilla, n. 16.01.
  44. North D.C. and Weingast B.R. (1989), Constitutions and commitment. The evolution of institutions governing public choice in seventeenth-century England, «The Journal of Economic History», 49, 4: 803-832.
  45. Ogilvie S. (2018), The European guilds: An economic analysis, Princeton.
  46. Oto-Peralias D. and Romero-Avila D. (2017), Historical frontiers and the rise of inequality: The case of the frontier of Granada, «Journal of the European Economic Association», 15, 1: 54-98.
  47. Pamuk S. (2007), The Black Death and the origins of the 'Great Divergence' across Europe, 1300-1600 The Black Death and the origins of the ‘Great Divergence’ across Europe, 1300-1600, «European Review of Economic History», 11: 289-311.
  48. Piketty T. (2014), Capital in the 21st Century, Cambridge.
  49. Pocock J.G.A. (2016), The Machiavellian Moment. Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition, Princeton.
  50. Prak M. (2005), The Dutch Republic in the Seventeenth Century. The Golden Age, Cambridge.
  51. Prak M. (2015), Citizens, soldiers and civic militias in late medieval and early modern Europe, in «Past & Present», 228, 1: 93-123.
  52. Rothenberg W.B. (1985), The emergence of a capital market in rural Massachusetts, 1730–1838, «The Journal of Economic History», 45, 4: 781-808.
  53. Scheffer M., van bavel b., van de Leemput I.A. and van Nes E.H. (2017)., Inequality in nature and society, «Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences», 114, 50: 13154-13157.
  54. Scheidel W. (2017), The Great Leveler. Violence and the History of Inequality from the Stone Age to the Twenty-First Century, Princeton.
  55. Scheve K. and Stasavage D. (2012), Democracy, war, and wealth. Lessons from two centuries of inheritance taxation, «American Political Science Review», 106, 1: 81-102.
  56. Schulze W. (1983), «Geben Aufruhr und Aufstand Anlaß zu neuen heilsamen Gesetzen«. Beobachtungen über die Wirkungen bäuerlichen Widerstands in der frühen Neuzeit, in Id. (ed.), Aufstände, Revolten und Prozesse. Beiträge zu bäuerlichen Widerstandsbewegungen im frühneuzeitlichen Europa, Stuttgart: 261-285.
  57. Serrão J.V. and Santos R. (2013), Land policies and land markets. Portugal late eighteenth and early nineteenth century, in Béaur G. et al. (eds.), Property Rights, Land Markets and Economic Growth in the European Country Side (13th-20th Centuries), Turnhout: 317-342.
  58. Soens T. (2006), Explaining deficiencies of water management in the late medieval Flemish Coastal Plain, 13th-16th centuries, in Greef H. and ‘t Hart M.C. (eds.), Jaarboek voor Ecologische Geschiedenis 2005/2006. Water Management, Communities, and Environment. The Low Countries in Comparative Perspective, c. 1000-c. 1800, Gent/Amsterdam: 35-62.
  59. Soens T. (2013), Flood security in the medieval and early modern North Sea area. A question of entitlement?, «Environment & History», 19, 2: 209-232.
  60. Soltow L. (1979), Wealth distribution in Denmark’, «Scandinavian economic history review» 27, 2: 121-138.
  61. Somers M.R. (1993), Citizenship and the place of the public sphere. Law, community, and political culture in the transition to democracy, «American Sociological Review», 58, 5: 587-620.
  62. Stayer J.M. (1972), Anabaptists and the Sword, Lawrence.
  63. ‘t Hart M.C. (1993), The Making of a Bourgeois State. War, Politics and Finance during the Dutch Revolt, Manchester.
  64. Tits-Dieuaide M.J. (1975), Les tables des pauvres dans les anciennes principautés belges au moyen âge, «Tijdschrift voor geschiedenis», 88: 562–583.
  65. Vallance E. (2013), A Radical History of Britain. Visionaries, Rebels and Revolutionaries - the Men and Women who Fought for our Freedoms, Hachette.
  66. van Bavel B. (2019), Open societies before market economies: Historical analysis, in «Socio-economic Review» 10.1093/soceco/mwz007
  67. van Bavel B.J.P. (2010), Manors and Markets. Economy and Society in Low Countries 500-1600, Oxford.
  68. van Bavel B.J.P. (2016), The Invisible Hand? How Market Economies have Emerged and Declined since AD 500, Oxford.
  69. van Bavel B.J.P. (2019), Differentials, paper for the WINIR conference.
  70. van Bavel B.J.P. and Rijpma A. (2016), How important were formalized charity and social spending before the rise of the welfare state? A long-run analysis of selected western European cases, 1400–1850, «The Economic History Review», 69, 1: 159-187.
  71. van Bavel B.J.P., Curtis D., Dijkman J., Hannaford M., De Keyzer M., van Onacker E. and Soens T. (forthcoming), Disasters and History, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
  72. van Besouw B. (2019), On the Economic Consequences of Warfare in Early Modern Northwest Europe: Four Conceptual and Empirical Contributions, PhD thesis, Utrecht.
  73. van Cruyningen P. (2014), From disaster to sustainability. Floods, changing property relations and water management in the south-western Netherlands, c.1500-1800, «Continuity & Change», 29, 2: 241-265.
  74. van der Linden H. (1955), De cope: bijdrage tot de rechtsgeschiedenis van de openlegging der Hollands-Utrechtse laagvlakte, Assen.
  75. van Leeuwen M.H.D. (2012), Guilds and middle-class welfare, 1550-1800: provisions for burial, sickness, old age, and widowhood, «Economic history review» 65: 61–90.
  76. Van Onacker E. (2014), Leaders of the Pack? Village Elites and Social Structures in the Fifteenth-and Sixteenth-Century Campine Area, University of Antwerp, Antwerp.
  77. Van Zanden J.L. (1995), Tracing the beginning of the Kuznets curve. Western Europe during the early modern period, «Economic History Review», 48, 1995, n. 4, pp. 643-664.
  78. Whittle J. C. (2000), The Development of Agrarian Capitalism. Land and Labour in Norfolk 1440-1580, Oxford.
  79. Zuijderduijn J. (2019), Assets frozen in time. Intergenerational transfers, mobility of capital within families and economic growth in Italy and the Low Countries, 1000-1800, First draft, Utrecht.

Export citation

Selected format

Usage statistics policy

  • 26Chapter Downloads

Cita come:
Van Bavel, B.; 2020; Looking for the islands of equality in a sea of inequality. Why did some societies in pre-industrial Europe have relatively low levels of wealth inequality?. Firenze, Firenze University Press.


Distributori


Indici e aggregatori bibliometrici